Should I get a kitchen island or peninsula in my renovation?

The choice between a kitchen island and peninsula depends on your space, traffic flow, and how you use your kitchen. Islands work best in larger kitchens (minimum 10x12 feet) with good circulation, while peninsulas are ideal for smaller or galley-style kitchens where you want extra counter space without blocking movement.

Space and Layout Considerations

Kitchen islands require significant space to function properly. You need at least 42 inches of clearance on all sides for comfortable movement, and 48 inches is even better if multiple people cook together. In Ottawa's typical home layouts - from Centrepointe townhomes to older homes in the Glebe - islands work well in open-concept designs where the kitchen flows into living areas. They create a natural gathering spot and can house your sink, cooktop, or additional storage.

Peninsulas extend from existing cabinetry or walls, making them perfect for smaller Ottawa kitchens or those with challenging layouts. They provide similar benefits to islands - extra prep space, storage, and seating - but take up less floor space. This makes them ideal for bungalows in Nepean or older homes in Westboro where square footage is at a premium.

Ottawa-Specific Considerations

In Ottawa's housing market, both options can add significant value, but the choice should match your home's style and neighborhood expectations. Century homes in areas like Old Ottawa South often benefit from peninsulas that complement the original layout, while newer builds in Kanata or Barrhaven can accommodate larger islands.

Cost differences in the Ottawa market are significant. A basic peninsula addition typically runs $5,000-$12,000, while islands range from $8,000-$25,000 depending on size, materials, and whether you're adding plumbing or electrical. Islands require more complex planning for utilities - especially if you want a sink or cooktop - which means additional permits through the City of Ottawa and coordination with licensed trades.

Functionality and Lifestyle

Consider how you actually use your kitchen. If you frequently entertain or have kids doing homework while you cook, an island creates a natural command center. The 360-degree access makes it easy to serve food, help with projects, or just chat with family. However, islands can disrupt the classic kitchen work triangle between sink, stove, and refrigerator.

Peninsulas maintain better workflow in smaller spaces while still providing that coveted breakfast bar seating. They're also easier to wire for electrical outlets and don't require the complex floor planning that islands demand.

For a free consultation to discuss which option works best in your specific Ottawa home layout, contact Justyn Rook Contracting. We can help you visualize both options and ensure your choice maximizes both function and your renovation investment.