Acrylic vs porcelain bathtub which is better?

For most Ottawa homeowners, porcelain (actually porcelain-enameled steel or cast iron) bathtubs offer better long-term value despite higher upfront costs, while acrylic provides an affordable option with decent performance for budget-conscious renovations.

When choosing between these materials, you're really comparing durability, maintenance, and cost over the life of your bathroom. Porcelain-enameled tubs - whether on steel or cast iron bases - typically last 20-30 years with proper care. The hard, non-porous surface resists stains, scratches, and fading exceptionally well. In Ottawa's hard water conditions, porcelain handles mineral buildup better and cleans more easily with standard bathroom cleaners. The main drawbacks are higher initial cost ($800-2,500 installed) and significant weight, especially cast iron versions that may require floor reinforcement in older Ottawa homes.

Acrylic tubs offer excellent value for budget renovations, typically costing $400-1,200 installed. They're lightweight, retain heat well (great for our cold Ottawa winters), and come in numerous colors and styles. Modern acrylic tubs are much more durable than older fiberglass units, often lasting 10-15 years. However, they can scratch more easily, may show wear patterns from cleaning, and lighter colors can yellow over time, especially near windows with UV exposure.

For Ottawa's climate specifically, both materials handle temperature changes well, but porcelain's thermal mass means it stays warmer longer once heated - a nice benefit during our long winters. If you're planning a secondary suite conversion (a JRC specialty), acrylic often makes more sense due to lower costs and easier installation in tight basement spaces.

Professional installation considerations include proper support framing for both materials, but porcelain requires more robust structural support. In older Ottawa homes with original plumbing, we often recommend upgrading drain assemblies regardless of tub choice, as 50+ year old connections may not seal properly with new fixtures.

My recommendation: Choose porcelain if this is your forever home and primary bathroom - the durability justifies the cost. Go with quality acrylic for guest baths, rental units, or when budget is the primary concern. Either way, proper installation with adequate support and quality plumbing connections matters more than the material choice.

For a free assessment of your specific bathroom renovation needs and to discuss which option works best for your Ottawa home, contact Justyn Rook Contracting.